Did you not hear him? It is his FIRST add-on...
So? If everyone could use this excuse, the Add-ons section would be filled with more crap than it already is.
Besides, if people criticize it, he could learn what mistakes he made, and not make them again.
I think we just need a normal red tack that's properly smooth-shaded.
Nah, look at everything else. Even light bulbs were flat shaded.