GAH I know it's a moth! I just wish I could find a picture that could convince you.
Look at its head and your bug's head:

That is the head of this thing;

Also, it still doesn't have the jaw structure my bug has, the tongue is just rolled up.
Sorry to keep trying to prove you wrong, but I really need to figure out what this actually is.
I am going to ask my biology teacher if he knows what it is, I have biology on Wednesday so we may know for sure on Wednesday.
Details on my bug;
- Pincer-like jaws
- Hairy
- Has wings
- Has eyes inside of head, not outside like most moths
- About the length of an adult's thumb