Not my point, I looked through some of his recent posts. All he ever says is "No", he should give a reason to prevent further mistakes from the builder.
As Random said, it is his choice if he wants to give tips or not. It isn't our job to give advice to what seems like 2 new apps every day. I will normally give tips on every vote, that is my choice; some NWB members don't give advice, that is their choice. It isn't up to you guys to tell us how to undergo voting on apps, nor to judge our members in how they go about handling clan related matters.
Now, on to the app:
Sorry, but I will have to go with
No as well. The boat seems to have a strange shape in my eyes, it looks like it is kind of squished. Adding to that there are other various parts that look a bit odd.
But as Random said, I would speak to Builder. Out of all of the NWB members, he is best at boats.