Author Topic: Weird math problem...  (Read 2331 times)

I got the weirdest problem @ homeschool today.

On a lonely stretch of road, two travelers came upon a wealthy man who had been attacked by robbers. the wealthy man asked the travelers if they had any food to share, as all his possessions had been taken from him and he was hungry.
The first traveler said "I have five loaves of bread" and the second traveler said "I have three loaves of bread.
The wealthy man replied "Let us share these loaves as true companions would, when we return to my village, i will happily pay you one gold coin for each loaf that you have shared."
The travelers agreed and shared the loaves evenly among all three men. when they arrived in town where the wealthy man lived they had eaten all the bread. the wealthy man immediately went into his house and came out with eight gold coins. he gave five coins to the first traveler, and three to the second traveler. thinking that he had paid his debt properly he began to thank the travelers, but the irst traveler interrupted, saying, "I believe there has been a mistake in your payment. i should of recieved seven coins, and my companion one. The wealthy man questioned the first travelers math, but after the traveler explained his reasoning, the wealthy man, as well as the second traveler, agreed his math was correct. the wealthy man gave the first traveler seven, and the second 1.
What did the first traveler say?

"I'm a greedy stuff hole that doesn't give a forget about my companion!"

Wait, seven? How did one guy get seven coins?

Hmmmm...

Edit: Was the second traveler carrying some of the first man's loaves?
« Last Edit: November 25, 2009, 08:53:55 AM by Zenthrox »

The second traveler only had one loaf of bread originally while the first had seven. The first gave two loaves to the second traveler before they met the wealthy man.

Maybe the first guy gave the second guy 2 loaves beforehand?

Maybe, just maybe, there wasn't any bread to begin with!

Maybe there is no bread, anywhere?

Seriously though, did the first guy give two loaves to the second guy beforehand?

Off topic: The bread is a lie!

on topic: the first traveler said "I shared two loaves of bread with the second traveler before we met you. I originally had 7." maybe?

Since he gave a gold coin for every shared loaf, the first traveler must have shared two loaves beforehand :)
« Last Edit: November 25, 2009, 08:58:39 AM by SoulStealer »

^ Probably, because that's the only way I can see that the second traveler would give up two of his gold pieces.

"I'm a greedy stuff hole that doesn't give a forget about my companion!"


lol, im confused on it also. On Monday when i have home school again I'll get the answer and tell you guys lol

lol, im confused on it also. On Monday when i have home school again I'll get the answer and tell you guys lol

*headdesk*

I won't be able to sleep until Monday.

lol, im confused on it also. On Monday when i have home school again I'll get the answer and tell you guys lol
*headdesk* If it's homeschool why can't you ask now?

*headdesk* If it's homeschool why can't you ask now?

Maybe he's not at home?