Heres how it works; I judge the server on "BLOCK"-
Build quality - Are the builds there any good? Are there many of them? Is it made purely from 1x12x5s and firebricks? Correct use of EW?
Leadership - Are the admins kind? EW given within 3 requests? Spammers jailed or kicked?
Originality - Is it just another freebuild on RTB isles? Or is it a challenge on a custom made map with new scripts and items? Are the builds unique?
Custom settings - Includes game types and mods used, and whether these worked or not. Also includes LAG
Koolness- Overall rating, several ratings may be given on servers where people may have multiple tastes on what they do and don't like. Koolness is not an average of above ratings.
These are my own views and some might not agree with them these people are wrong
I will tend to review the servers that are up frequently rather than one-offs, unless the One-offs are pretty good.
23 Sept
Name: >Kap's Server<
Details: DigitalDesigner map
Build quality: 7/10 It hadn't been up long, but some cool traps and houses were made
Leadership: 9/10 Two friendly admins gave EW instantly, set up a DM between admins and other players for whoever wanted a fight, and protected builders. Knew a lot about the game
Originality: 8/10 Made traps and messed about on an uncommonly played map. Unique builds
Custom stuff: 5/10 Basic RTB but with a downloaded map
Koolness: 8.5/10
Made a fort wars game, with some really good builds. I had to leave before the fight but I know it would have been fun. Recommended.