Poll

Should Pluto have been demoted to 'minor planet'?

Yes
29 (45.3%)
No
35 (54.7%)

Total Members Voted: 64

Author Topic: Pluto vs. NASA  (Read 1829 times)

Tom

Actually 2, of course they might be finding even more.


Yes. We have a set of rules to define celestial bodies. Pluto did not fit into the "Planet" category because it doesn't dominate its own orbit. It's a Dwarf Planet, so is its "moon", Charon.
Actually 2, of course they might be finding even more.


That 2003 UB313 is "Eris"

I have a great interest in astronomy
*highfives*

Pluto is still a planet to me :c

Dwarf Planet

Polish a turd it's still a turd. Pluto is a planet, says so in the name.

Dwarf Planet

Polish a turd it's still a turd. Pluto is a planet, says so in the name.
i think you know what i'm trying to say... (as in its not a dwarf planet to me...)


Pluto isn't a planet anymore because the definition now requires it to clear its orbit of debris.

New Poll: Do we care?

Well the Keiper Belt beyond Pluto shows some evidence that Pluto is maybe an asteroid.

Pluto is waaaay too big to be an asteroid. Large enough for its gravity to form it into a sphere = not asteroid.

Pluto isn't a planet anymore because the definition now requires it to clear its orbit of debris.
Earth isn't a planet then. Ask the Dinosaurs why.  :cookieMonster:

I blame the brits.
I don't really think so, I guess...

I BLAME THE EDUCATIONAL SYSTEM.

Earth isn't a planet then. Ask the Dinosaurs why.  :cookieMonster:
How the forget else do you expect planets to clear out debris, by swatting it away with a broom?

Earth isn't a planet then. Ask the Dinosaurs why.  :cookieMonster:

The asteroid entered its orbit. It wasn't always there.

Jupiter is scary.

Jupiter is an starfish.
I was talking to the moon the other day and that starfish wouldn't leave us alone.