Personally, I think any sort of LP cuts out a lot of what makes the game interesting. Things like doing side quests for the ever eccentric community of Twin Pe.....erm, Greenvale or the random stupid stuffe that just happens such as York talking to "Zack" about Kevin Bacon and Deadly Spawn. From what I've heard once, Swery didn't mean to incorporate shooting into the game but the publisher "requested" that it be added into their. Even if the shooting segments were good, it still wouldn't really fit into Deadly Premonition. You just have to ignore the "Gamey" part of this. It's a hard game to like, especially at first where game breaking bugs, bad framerate issues, outdated graphics, bad audio, and the such may put off the less tolerable. But if you hang on, you can find some diamons in the rough. Really, I never took the game as anything other than a really bad but laughable horror movie. And you know what, I've almost forgotten what laughter tastes like in an industry trying to hard to take itself seriously.
So, FK and Sinner sandwiches anyone?
Here's a particulary funny (And not so Spoilery) Cutscene to get yourself acquainted with the strangeness of this game....
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qltjIXLx5Cwhttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-bsXolnsO_gAnd my personal favorite:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IUO0uuk5-QYSo yeah, also chipmunks make monkey noises to for some reason