Providing today's lower class with help to raise them up just shifts different people into the 'lower class' area. The notion that black people are inherently less deserving of the lower class position than other races because of their history is in itself tribal. I'm not saying that black people should be lower class, but I'm saying they're no more deserving than anyone else in the lower class to be raised from that level. That statement is race-neutral, not tribal.
I'd say you're begging the question of whether social programs actually create a 'new' lower class.
