Whats the deal

[crumper07]

I'm new and noticed there is a rivalry in between Athey123 and Madmitten.

How did this start and who is the biggest starfish?

[Ad Bot]

[crumper07]

No i will not take sides

[King of losers]

Who is Athey123?

[eddierocks2000]

Who is Athey123?

[sir dooble]

I know of Madmitten, and he's cool and all.

Never heard of Athey123. Know nothing of any hatred between the two.
If anything, this sounds more like you are/know Athey in-game and don't like Madmitten.
Unless of course you can give us a link to his profile.

[SeventhSandwich]

Who is Athey123?

[Sebster 105]

Who is Athey123?

[IkeTheGeneric]

I remember Athey123

[Sebster 105]

I remember Athey123

Holy stuff why do I agree with you

[sir dooble]

I remember Athey123

After that, I only saw 1 post of him being stupid against Madmitten.

Madmitten being 'mean' to him was just how the topic goes.
It's not a rivalry when everyone was hating on him.

[Fizzles]

with airline food

[A.R.C.]

with airline food

forget your stuff I was going to do that

[Oasis]

with airline food

forget your stuff I was going to do that

lol'd   

[Madmitten]

athey is a dumbass

[Fizzles]

forget your stuff I was going to do that

nanny nanny boo boo