As far as I can see, "rian" is a forgettard. He, like Tom/Chuck, is also evidently immature. That makes his drama topic "invalid", despite most of it being true about Tom/Chuck being an idiot. Tom/Chuck just has been around for a time period and earned rep for said duration. That does not, however, mean he is above idiocy.
I agree that this is a "stupid thread" because of who posted it, but that does not mean its false.