Opinions - Should we destroy the last bit of the smallpox disease?

[battlebrain]

of course the poll answers are

first person
modern
shooter

[Ad Bot]

[yuki]

Most important element? Immersiveness. You know a game is good when you're absolutely immersed in it.

[Madmitten]

Most important element? Immersiveness. You know a game is good when you're absolutely immersed in it.

seems like it'd be gameplay/story


the thing that makes a game, is gameplay.
a generic storyline and controls that make the game especially dodgy are OK as long as its fun to play

[PowerDag]

Lol, Wii haters
Every console is good in a way.

[ChexGuy331]

Controls+Gameplay

[Azzurolix]

Jiggle physics.

[Kingdaro]

Whoever said Graphics is a cigarette.

Obvious answer is Gameplay because the Gameplay is pretty much the game itself.

[Smash Fan]

Multiplayer.
But depends of game.
There are games that were born for singleplayer.

[Solid]

nudity

[Azzurolix]

nudity

First thing we agree on :D!

[Altered]

gameplay or story

[Fredulus]

"overall quality"
all parts matter.

[carolcat]

Gameplay is always an important part, and story is as well. Games with a good story can be interesting, intriguing, and such. Graphics are mainly for immersing the player in the game, so they can create different moods: cheery, frightening, and such. You wouldn't want difficult-to-learn and hard to remember controls, so that along with graphics aren't incredibly important. Heck, just as long as I know what it's trying to get across, I could care less about the graphics in a game.

I say gameplay/story are most important.

[IsaacKronenFaust]

BioWare is the most important Game Element.

[Fredulus]

I think "Gameplay" is an overly broad and therefore stupid term. What defines good gameplay? Everyone says "i'm a real gamer, gameplay is all that matters." Well what are you calling gameplay?