So people don't like it because of what it could've been?
Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 3 could have been a game that brought something new to the table
I dislike it because it is not, exactly the same as Duke Nukem Forever.
After over a decade of waiting most people were expecting something excellent, not something that was obviously rushed out in the professional equivalent of the Ludum Dare timeframe. I'm not referring to it being buggy; I'm referring to it being part of a very, very old franchise that hasn't seen a new entry in so long adhering to the latest and most popular trend in best-selling fad-games for cigarette-dames. We expected, at the very least, for it to be similar to the games of its heyday, with something new and interesting, not essentially a tongue-in-cheek reskin of the same games we've had re-released year after year for a third of the time we waited for this one.