I've decided to host a 1v1 server with PIRATES and stuff and I need some weapons :C
Wooden Tomahawk:

Basically a wooden curved axe. Used for bashing. The axe would have a 26% chance to make the player tumble.
Caltrop:

You pick it up, and click it to throw it on the ground. Stepping on it deals a great amount of damage, and once stepped on, it will disappear.
Buckler:

An iron shield. When hit, your character would 'parry', you would take 75% of the damage dealt, and the 25% hurts the attacker. Clicking with the shield bashes the player backwards.
Cutlass:

A curved sword. Normally used for slashing, but if you right-click, you do a stabbing motion and do more damage at the cost of not being able to move for a second.
Flintlock Pistol:

Small range, bad accuracy but good damage. Fires at a rather quick pace.
Matchlock Musket:

Slow to fire, great range and accuracy and good damage.