Closest PlayNTrade to me in in New Hampshire. The area I live in Massachusetts is fairly close to New Hampshire. I'll give them a call.
EDIT: If I bought the game from there, I would be able to do this. But the trade-in value, depending on the price they sell the game, and the quality of my copy, can be up around $20-$30 in credit. That is much better than what they offer at GameStop.