Author Topic: Thanksgiving is about Socialism vs. Capitalism  (Read 1019 times)

Today in my U.S. history class we had to read 3 articles about the origin of Thanksgiving, and then write an essay comparing/contrasting them

But the real interest here is one of the articles. The first two generally followed the widely-accepted story of Thanksgiving: Pilgrims are starving, Native Americans show them some survival skills, and then everyone's so happy that a goddamn holiday is made.
The third one, however, was extremely far from the widely-accepted story. It basically claimed that there was no such Native American influence on the pilgrims' survival and that the starving was due to the pilgrims using a socialist economy at first, but everyone was greedy so they didn't want to contribute to the community stockpile. Then it says that they switched to a Capitalist, free-market system and suddenly everyone was thriving. Then it states that Free Markets are the "only source of abundance" and Thanksgiving is about us giving thanks to God for the country having free markets.

I looked up the article online, so you can read it here.



TL;DR:
Some guy wrote an article that everything we know about thanksgiving is a lie and it's actually a celebration of capitalism.


Discuss.


This guy must get a job at Fox!

Political flame war ignited.

uh


the Native Americans did help though. :| nvm disregard


Wowe

Obvious bollocks is obvious

Basically a puritan holiday was turned into a national holiday and big buisness use it to sell turkey, alcohol, then the next day sell bunch of chinese manufactured stuff that will be used in December. 

Just goes to show Obama supports famine, damn lefty.



Thanksgiving is about turkey


Thanksgiving is about turkey
its about cranberry sauce obivously you uneducated broad
jk

its about cranberry sauce obivously you uneducated broad
jk

I agree with this

Just goes to show Obama supports famine, damn lefty.
I should've put that in the response paper thing, ffff

So here, just like what happened to the USSR, Socialism caused famines?