Poll

Should a school be able to perm. suspend for carrying a pocket knife?

Yes.
31 (33.7%)
No.
61 (66.3%)

Total Members Voted: 92

Author Topic: My best friend got permanently suspended.  (Read 3237 times)

I thought you and your friends had a history of getting in trouble, and the pocket knife was just the last straw.

Or was that someone else?

Uh? Are you sure you aren't thinking of Alyx Vance? I've got a clean record, as well as my friend.

Maybe for self defense if like a lockdown happens and he can't get somewhere safe.

because a pocket knife will stop someone five yards away with an AR15 and a shotgun

He shouldn't have had the knife with him, but that's still a bit too harsh of a punishment. They're probably just paranoid after recent events.

-snip-
This is completely wrong.
As an american, you have a right to carry a pocket knife less than a specific measurement. If it was less, it's fine.
He should have told the school it was for self defense. The school should have just confiscated it and give him detention or something.

I could understand detention or suspension for something like this
but permanent suspension?
what?

By the way, permanent suspension is called expulsion.
(verb: expel)

permanent suspension means expulsion lol

but yes bringing a weapon into school is pretty stupid

Permantly suspended for bringing a pocket knife?? Wtf
Can I like bring all of you that are stuck in bullstuff schools to my school? Its so much better and relaxed here. Oh bring a pocket knife? No problem just don't let the principal see it and your fine. If a teacher saw it they would just say put it away and don't ever get it out in his/her sight again

Edit- a few of my teachers also carry around pocket knifes to open up boxes and whatnot

Get caught with drugs? 1 year to half a semester suspended and there's even programs they have so you can catch up on the credits you missed so you can graduate.

Fights? 2 days to a week OSS

Anything else? They really don't care until it becomes a problem
aaaa I'm grateful for my school and wish you guys didn't have such bad ones :c
« Last Edit: April 11, 2013, 04:48:21 PM by sorrel »

why did he bring it
it's his fault :I

Of course he deserved it.

He brought a knife to school.

i always have a pocket knife. but you still cant bring them to schools and court houses and post offices (i still do) and such stuff.

idiot deserved it.

Stupid to bring a pocket knife to school.

It's also stupid to claim it's for self defence.
If you claim it's for self defence then you are claiming that you have it as a weapon, not a tool.
You can't bring a weapon into a school for any reason.

Courts and police don't give a stuff over the reasons you have for bringing a deadly weapon into a school. And the school shouldn't either.


Last year a kid at my school forgot he had his boyscout knife in his pants and some kid reported him. He got a week in juvi as well as other things.

at the school i used to go to you could get suspended for drawing guns (by "guns" i mean stick figures holding L-shaped objects)
i know this because it happened to me