SPOILERS - Browsing the internet has given me the impression that it's a stuff game interactive story.
[SPOILER]It seems pretty obvious to me those very positive reviews are mostly explained by the Anitas in game journalism today, sadly.
The main reason : in this game, the homoloveuality of Sam -the teenager- is almost entirely irrelevant. Her love story is touching, even moving at times, but aside from the fact that her parents might get angry, had she been straight instead of gay, everything could have gone exactly the same way.
Sadly, the homoloveuality in this story is plain useless, and there merely to say "look, we have homoloveuality in our game". It isn't "shoved down your throat", but since it has no meaning, doesn't actually personalize Sam nor Katie -which is the character you portray, yet is even less constructed and personalized than Sam-, doesn't make the story move forward nor goes through the "process" of a homoloveual going through this "discovery" -shame, surprise, being excited, experimental, etc.-, it has nothing to do there.
In a way, it isn't even "wrong", since it's basically going through this with a "it's life, that's nothing but life"; but it's interesting only when it's your life or someone you're close to's life... life your sister. Since you play Katie, you SHOULD care about Sam's whereabouts, but... the developers gave no stuff about Katie, so why should we feel like we "are" Katie ourselves ? And if we don't care about feeling the way Katie does, why should we care about how Sam feels ?..
Homoloveuality in this game is basically useless and brings nothing.
$20 for a 1 hour interactive story? HAHAHAHAHAHA-
you're kidding, right?
right?
Persona 4 had a better story and it's a forgetin' Japanese game from 2008.