map looks uninspired and boring, and overall kind of copy and pasty.

and, because the two pirate ships where people(im assuming, because there really isnt much detail in this topic) spawn is right opposite each other, there really isnt much of a need for this whole island. it seemed like its there just because it can.
"Control points are not necessary to win"

last of all, the concept of the server is "tdm but with pirates and pirate weapons". are there any boats you can ride, sea travel or something?
ideas:
maybe you could make heaps of islands scattered and big pirate ships on either end of the map. then, people must use dinghys to go with a team to an island and fight for that island and capture it.
team with most captures wins.
EDIT: added some stuff / changed picture scale