Minecraft made me feel a genuine, visceral sense of forget WHERE DID THAT COME FROM
Dust: An Elysian Tale and Cave Story gave me similar senses of "did that just happen oh my god" -- both impressed and shaken at various circumstances
Sid Meier's Civilization V made me feel suspicion and worry, watching the movements of militaristic neighbors and trying to prepare defenses without losing money
Call of Duty: Ghosts made me feel a lengthy, seething resentment toward myself and Infinity Ward