Good in theory, horrible in practice. Didn't valve say they were closing the service down? What ever happened with that
I can't recall exactly, but I think it was just Gabe who mentioned he'd like to close it down and start with something different.
But I suppose either the rest of the company disagreed with him, or there was too much complaint against it, or Greenlight is just too profitable.
Greenlight is a rather good concept, and it's certainly nice that it lets Indie developers who have worked hard, get their game onto a platform where they can get it some attention, as with Blockland.
I don't particularly like the apparent system they have for Greenlighting games though, which mostly seems to be to choose the game with the most votes gathered quickly.
That sounds like the best way to scope which games people want and are profitable, but in reality, people are loving idiots, and they'll vote on mass for stupid games, just because they know the game is stupid.
It's the same way in which people will actually give money to Kickstarter projects for stuff like Potato Salad.
And with a limited number of slots given in any round of greenlighting, it's unfair on developers who have worked hard to create an actual game, that people can play, with good quality, and have been trying hard to rack up support for their game. When we were in Greenlight we certainly waited a long time (about a year) while some truly awful stuff got greenlit ahead of us, because they were popular for being stupid, or already had lots and lots of support and were going to get funded and published by themselves anyway. For example, that one simulator game about sleeping, and the Yogscast game (which got cancelled).