I legitimately found Goat Simulator fun for like an hour. Then I stopped playing. Maybe with all the maps it has now it's even better.
The problem is that it only works once. This game basically ruined Greenlight because of the crap "simulators" thinking they can make it big by being terrible. What they don't understand is that Goat Simulator is a real game and is fun.
Nobody loves it BECAUSE it is terrible. I enjoyed it because of the freedom to roam around and find interesting Easter Eggs, often poorly made but humorous. It's the same sort of charm as Garry's Mod.
And you know what? I'd still rather play this than boring-ass DayZ.