Author Topic: Change My View On Race in Education  (Read 1713 times)

So I've been writing my college essay and some past experiences clicked together in my head and I had a pretty disturbing conclusion. I never really thought much of race, but it seems really apparent to me that I have extra benefits in education compared to my peers, which though I benefit, I still believe is absolutely disgusting.

I've always been an average writer at best. I know that there are many other students at my school who are deserving of higher marks than I am. But I've never received below a B in English after learning one simple way to add substance to my essays and get them done quicker. Most students will make biblical allusions if relevant. I decided, after making biblical allusions in essays and receiving mediocre grades (C to B range) to use some of my own culture's myths instead in my essays. After including the Creek myths instead of the standard biblical/Greek myths and personal anecdotes about my experience growing up Creek outside of my own culture, my grades shot up to B to A range. I haven't taken any conscious steps to improve my writing, but somehow my grade went up by painting myself as an underrepresented and oppressed minority.

The argument I'm trying to make is that by being in a minority group, the experience of education becomes SIGNIFICANTLY easier. I think this is absolutely disgusting and teachers who participate in such grade boosting on account of race should be reprimanded severely. I got together with some other students to write a formal letter of complaint to the school and this is my last chance to change my view before we write the letter. We verified that the grade boost wasn't a result of using a "unique" allusion because we had my french-canadian friend use a Lakota creation story in her essay and put her sweat, blood, and tears into perfecting it and she got a B- while I spent 15 minutes on mine and got an A-. A full letter grade on account of race simply isn't acceptable in my eyes.

Convince me, forums. Am I right in trying to purge this injustice or is it "acceptable" to throw away academic integrity because of the terrible treatment of a particular group in history?

how are C's and B's mediocre?

i'm sorry but
But I've never received below a B in English after learning one simple way to add substance to my essays and get them done quicker.
WRITERS HATE HIM

So I've been writing my college essay and some past experiences clicked together in my head and I had a pretty disturbing conclusion. I never really thought much of race, but it seems really apparent to me that I have extra benefits in education compared to my peers, which though I benefit, I still believe is absolutely disgusting.

I've always been an average writer at best. I know that there are many other students at my school who are deserving of higher marks than I am. But I've never received below a B in English after learning one simple way to add substance to my essays and get them done quicker. Most students will make biblical allusions if relevant. I decided, after making biblical allusions in essays and receiving mediocre grades (C to B range) to use some of my own culture's myths instead in my essays. After including the Creek myths instead of the standard biblical/Greek myths and personal anecdotes about my experience growing up Creek outside of my own culture, my grades shot up to B to A range. I haven't taken any conscious steps to improve my writing, but somehow my grade went up by painting myself as an underrepresented and oppressed minority.

The argument I'm trying to make is that by being in a minority group, the experience of education becomes SIGNIFICANTLY easier. I think this is absolutely disgusting and teachers who participate in such grade boosting on account of race should be reprimanded severely. I got together with some other students to write a formal letter of complaint to the school and this is my last chance to change my view before we write the letter. We verified that the grade boost wasn't a result of using a "unique" allusion because we had my french-canadian friend use a Lakota creation story in her essay and put her sweat, blood, and tears into perfecting it and she got a B- while I spent 15 minutes on mine and got an A-. A full letter grade on account of race simply isn't acceptable in my eyes.

Convince me, forums. Am I right in trying to purge this injustice or is it "acceptable" to throw away academic integrity because of the terrible treatment of a particular group in history?

well the way I view it is that writing papers is total bs and english class sucks richard

Well what is your race? I think the only reason biblical allusions are graded less is because they're used so darn much. Do you explicitly state that you're alluding to Greek fantasies?

And on the other hand, is the french-canadian girl explicitly stating so?


how are C's and B's mediocre?
I'd say C range is mediocre, B range is okay, and A is where I want to be. I just am upset that the school system treats minorities like helpless children who wouldn't pass if not for grade boosting and affirmative action programs.

i'm sorry butWRITERS HATE HIM
I knew someone was going to say this


well the way I view it is that writing papers is total bs and english class sucks richard

Well what is your race? I think the only reason biblical allusions are graded less is because they're used so darn much. Do you explicitly state that you're alluding to Greek fantasies?

And on the other hand, is the french-canadian girl explicitly stating so?
I'm Muscogee Creek and Choctaw. I used the stories I heard growing up in my essays and specifically stated where they were coming from (passed down through the family.) My friend used Lakota Sioux myths, which are fairly comparable to the ones I was using. The only difference between her and I is race.


how are C's and B's mediocre?

they aren't, just that the american school system has evolved into this:

a - okay
b - meh, do better
c - near failing
d - student has severe mental problems
f - in my district, they're never even given out

c - near failing
d - student has severe mental problems
f - in my district, they're never even given out
yeah, that's not normal


a - okay
b - meh, do better
c - near failing
d - student has severe mental problems
f - in my district, they're never even given out

america's education standards suck richard

they aren't, just that the american school system has evolved into this:

a - okay
b - meh, do better
c - near failing
d - student has severe mental problems
f - in my district, they're never even given out

Yeah my school district is ultra competitive so you're expected to get all A's, and anything less, even a few B's is considered mediocre or worse

they aren't, just that the american school system has evolved into this:

a - okay
b - meh, do better
c - near failing
d - student has severe mental problems
f - in my district, they're never even given out

B and below is pretty mediocre in my opinion. You won't do much getting Cs in college.

they aren't, just that the american school system has evolved into this:

a - okay
b - meh, do better
c - near failing
d - student has severe mental problems
f - in my district, they're never even given out

florida:

a - okay
b - okay
c - meh, do better
d - not too bad
f - you did your best

I'm Muscogee Creek and Choctaw. I used the stories I heard growing up in my essays and specifically stated where they were coming from (passed down through the family.) My friend used Lakota Sioux myths, which are fairly comparable to the ones I was using. The only difference between her and I is race.

well uh

Maybe you're just better at alluding to your stories? Otherwise it is probably race, sadly

I once had an English teacher that wouldn't grade half of the class, (so in my district that defaults to 100%) and then she'd give A's to the super popular student council kids, (she ran student council) then gave B's and C's to everyone she disliked, and when lazy, just a 90%. I hated her.

yeah, that's not normal

yeah, it's my district, with how "every kid gets a pat on the head"

I have never legitimately seen anyone get anything less than a C

B and below is pretty mediocre in my opinion. You won't do much getting Cs in college.

eh

Yeah my school district is ultra competitive so you're expected to get all A's, and anything less, even a few B's is considered mediocre or worse

Mine isn't at all, they just want to look good to the state