I almost feel bad for the kid because of guy yelling and scaring the crap out of him but I hope he learned a valuable lesson that stealing is wrong.
if he's old enough to look 14, I don't feel bad for him. he should know well by now that's wrong
however, the fact that he willingly gave it back, despite pie crust or the other guy not knowing he had it, is a good sign that he will probably not do it again