Graphics don't make a game. Playability and Community does
If they are so stuffty you can't play, then it does matter. Runescape fixed it, but there are still better graphic games out there. Playability? sucks. When you shoot a bow, the arrow lobs and hits perfectly in the center, which is gay, and all you do is sit and wait to die or win. Point and click fails. There aren't many other fighting choices, but alot of mmo's have a blocking system at least. Runescape is pretty much has to quality of a text browser game, except with graphics. The community sucks
Level100: "ZOMG u noob! nubcaek! i r betr then u. Cum tu tha wildy an i wl kill u noob!!!@11111
Level12: "Nowai!n i r smartr, and i have a gf so i ar cooler then you (which is obviously a lie), atleest i have a life!!!!!
10 years later
Level112: "I finally got here! I r teh bestest player evar!!!
also, people get mad over when they are hacked or someone calls them a noob and they abuse report abuse.
Edit:
You guys are doing the same thing to Runescape as everyone does to Roblox. You say it sucks to seem like you fit in.
Roblox is an okay game. Only noobs that try to fit in say its bad. Its the communtiy most of us hate. And runescape truely does suck