its not fail, but its not great, try remaking the model, but try to make it more 3-d and look like the Original Sword, i think it would get good comments then.
Ya know, all these crappy weapon add-ons wouldn't piss me off so much if every loving noob had to download every loving weapon to use in a freebuild where it would not actually have any use at all except to filter out players like me who don't want this stuff crapping up their addons folder.
i can make better weapons if someone could teach me how to use vertex in Milkshape...any takers?