Red Dead Redemption vs Grand Theft Auto IV

[Solid]

Which do you think is Rockstar's better game?

For me it's Red Dead Redemption, there's just more stuff to do and better gameplay and multiplayer for me. Plus I never really cared for the theme of GTA.

[Ad Bot]

[keonesan]

They both kinda suck. I only like gta4 because of the ragdoll and vehicle physics. Flying 1000 feet and living is fun! 

[Solid]

Why do they suck? Have you played both of them through the entire story? You can just say they suck when you haven't beaten both of them.

I used to say that for a lot of games until I actually played them and loved them. These games include: Fallout 3, RDR, GTA4, and others.

[Shinji]

They're both great in different ways.

[Kevdude]

They both have their strengths and weaknesses. Besides RDR is a western game and GTA is a modern game. These two differences make them incomparable besides both being sandbox games by Rockstar

[Solid]

Yes but which did you enjoy more?

[Kevdude]

Yes but which did you enjoy more?

RDR had a better singleplayer and GTA IV was better online =/ I guess RDR

[General Nick]

I have yet to play RDD but I'm loving GTA4.

[Solid]

RDR had a better singleplayer and GTA IV was better online =/ I guess RDR

Really? I liked online better in RDR :o

[Kevdude]

Really? I liked online better in RDR :o

I find it more enjoyable to blow cars and hundreds of civilians up than loving riding a horse for ever to find something to do

[keonesan]

Why do they suck? Have you played both of them through the entire story? You can just say they suck when you haven't beaten both of them.

I used to say that for a lot of games until I actually played them and loved them. These games include: Fallout 3, RDR, GTA4, and others.

Didn't play through the entire game because it runs like stuff on my comp. My new video card is coming in tomorrow though. 460GTX super clocked. I'll play more and see if I'll give it a better review.

[Kevdude]

Didn't play through the entire game because it runs like stuff on my comp. My new video card is coming in tomorrow though. 460GTX super clocked. I'll play more and see if I'll give it a better review.

RDR isn't on the PC

[keonesan]

RDR isn't on the PC

I was referring to GTA4 not RDR. I haven't played RDR but I watched gameplay vids and it doesn't interest me.

[dkamm65]

RDR isn't on the PC

I hope they make it for PC eventually.

[Kevdude]

I was referring to GTA4 not RDR. I haven't played RDR but I watched gameplay vids and it doesn't interest me.

So, to make a decision between two games, play one and judge one. Good job