As soon as the idea of a 'flying purple peanut of zazamaroon' is brought up, you form an opinion.
You can't say you don't believe in that which you don't know about, and you can't say you believe doesn't exist that which you are unaware of.
Ok, instead of the peanut thing, what if I was asked about the corbu? I would also say no. I might ask about it first, but since I never heard of such a thing, again I would say no. I cannot believe in something I don't know about.
Why can't all atheists be like this?
Ikr
Because the whole thing is so damn specific. It is just as valid as any other creation story that can be thought up. What makes it the true one?
I choose to not really think about the whole "where did we come from" question because I know it can't be answered. That's the whole idea.
How do you know it can't be answered if you don't investigate for yourself?
I believe Christianity is the true one because it is better than all the rest, and it's different than all the rest. Just look at the Books, A case for Christ, A case for a creator, and A case for faith. Those books are by an atheist that took a 2 year investigation as a journalist, and found that there is indeed evidence that Christianity is true.