I agree completely on that. Trynd for me is more of a one trick pony, kinda like Sion.
He hits hard but other than that what is really accomplished?
Every other carry seems to have some kind of nifty pocket utility.(almost every other carry)
K
For example, Yi's meditate. It gives him HP regen, armor, and magic resist during the channel. There's no outgoing damage during meditation, yet he's still a melee AD carry. Ashe has hawkshot, it's active is something you'd most likely see on a support, but Ashe is not a support. It's still incredibly useful, especially it's level 5 range. Lee Sin can shield himself and an ally. Jarvan, Garen, Udyr, and Riven all have an ability that helps them survive. Renekton's ult damage is not why people like it either. It's the bonus health and fury regen. Shaco probably has the most utility kit I've seen on an AD champ. He has fear traps, invisibility/flash, and can clone himself. Olaf's ultimate gives him armor, magic resist, and immunity to CC.
What does Tryn have? His easy-shutdown ult? A gapclosing spin? A slow that no one ever uses appropriately? A heal that barely helps him? He's all passive autoattacks. His heal is only good for the passive damage and escaping DoTs. His passive itself is for his autoattacks. His ult just begs for crowd control. He really doesn't have anything but that.