lol
the best gamers already have a reputation for being complete starfishs, i wouldn't take anything they say too seriously.
while this guy makes a few good points in the video, he also tends to say the same negative thing over and over again without actually going into detail about why he thinks of it that way. saying "it doesn't have any gameplay" several times in a row doesn't make it true. and realistically, it can't actually have absolutely zero gameplay, if you can play it and if it's a game (though this would heavily depend upon a person's definition of what makes up a game, sure).
i feel like the portion where he singles out certain quotes from phil to make him look bad was too biased. just because phil made a video game doesn't mean he has to act any more civilized than another person; he brags because he accomplished something, someone put him down for it so he retaliated; quite a few people naturally do that.
i don't doubt the authenticity of the negative points that were made in the video. i just feel like the guy who narrated it was picking the worst points about the game he could; just because it doesn't have enemies doesn't mean it doesn't have gameplay; it's actually called a puzzle(/platformer) game.
