Haha, oh man, time to tear some ass open.
If a game is good it should be able to appeal to everyone.
That is simply not how it works. By that logic there is no such thing as a good game.
MLP (which i personally believe is garbage) was made to appeal to young girls. You know the rest.
Beyond irrelevant.
The HUD is confusing
The HUD was designed assuming you have intelligence above that of a squirrel. There is nothing confusing about it, it is in fact one of the most well designed and straightforward HUDs in modern games because there are really just three gauges to keep track of and an inventory bar. If you cannot comprehend that, it is your own fault for having subpar intelligence.
the characters are wood
The game is not about the characters, they are there as a means to an end.
the fighting system is way too complicated for what the actual fighting is (dodge, hit, dodge hit)
This is again a matter of you not having the apparent brain power to process pushing buttons, they are not going to over simplify the system to appeal to people like you who are too lazy and/or stupid to learn how combat systems work. It's apparent you wouldn't last a second in any game that uses any form of button combinations.
the game has tons of inconveniences and small problems
Such as...? Elaborate if you're going to make stupid points so I can properly invalidate them.
the way of tutoring the player is the exact opposite of what is considered helpful: walls of text with out any interactivity.
There is a manual. Read it.
It's just grinding for more gear until you're at the point where you can grind for more gear.
You can fight well beyond your equipment level with the necessary level of skill. Keyword being skill, if you can't even figure out waht you're doing, of course you're going to trap yourself in a grinding rut, and that's your own fault.
From what I've heard, the multiplayer is fun, but even cancer is fun when you have friends around, so it doesn't count.
This was so astronomically handicapped I won't even bother myself.
But then again that's my opinion. If you like the game, feel free to do so. All I'm trying to do is to let OP know that the game is nowhere near anything supreme and that it probably isn't for him.
You can't say "yeah but that's my opinion" and then immediately say "my opinion is right spread the word." That is not how the world works. Also, more importantly, your opinion is bullstuff that's probably fueled by your general inability to play the game, none of the attempts you made at justifying your opinion are at all valid. The closest thing to legitimate is that the characters are flat, but that is because the characters don't matter. The only plausible point you had was on something that doesn't matter. Well done.