tell us the truth pie crust

[Flatflyer]

Well me and F3d were doing a little bit of searching and F3d found Mateo's Flickr page with this image:

Look at the girl on the right
now that image was Taken in 2011 meaning its about 3 years old, meaning Pie would've been about 12-13 at that time


now lets compare this to the original picture Pie posted of herself



Looks about the same.
similar hair color, fairly similar skin tone, same earrings, and most of the facial features are the same.

Judging by this I'm pretty sure we can confirm that pie is indeed a female.

[Ad Bot]

[awesomebread]

Or mateo could've posted a picture of his sister. I dunno this is still kinda confusing to me

[mus]

second one doesn't even look however old Pie Crust says he/she is

[Maxwell.]

I can't imagine that face and a 14 year old boy dating

[Steve5451²]

THE PLOT THICKENS
Pacha: theres a date the image was taken
Pacha: here
Pacha: http://puu.sh/9tS29/b6eb4cb3f7.png
Pacha: 2009

Pie Crust's date of birth is 1998, so he's 16. That means that picture is from when he was eleven.
Does this look like an eleven year old?

I think pie is the one on the left, looks like all the other images.

[Flatflyer]

Pie Crust's date of birth is 1998, so he's 16. That means that picture is from when he was eleven.
Does this look like an eleven year old?

I'm pretty sure that thing is wrong.

[F3d323]

we're not denying carlota's existance
just denying that carlota is not pc

[mus]

I can't imagine that face and a 14 year old boy dating

I can imagine it being the reason for flatflyer having an e-crush

[Maxwell.]

she looks 16 in the second picture though and 11 in the first one
and people are saying they are the same age what

[Steve5451²]

I'm pretty sure that thing is wrong.

Could very well be, but I'm assuming it's correct and pointing it towards evidence.
Most digital cameras have the wrong date though.

In the above images she looks like eleven. That's a lot of change for three years.

[Zay]

we're not denying carlota's existance
just denying that carlota is not pc

pretty much this

[SquartleTurtle]

we're not denying carlota's existance
just denying that carlota is not pc

carlota is a personal computer?
she sounds hot

[SlayerZ99]

do you have proof that it's photoshopped? no, you don't. you just refuse to believe otherwise because everyone here is stubborn. I'm not saying it wasn't, I'm just saying that no matter how much proof somebody threw at this thread that the ID wasn't shopped almost if not everyone that currently believes it is would still believe it.

uh the "C" is not the correct font and is abruptly cut off
the "R" and "A" are taken from Roizman


We could offer all the proof that the thing was photoshopped and you'd be too stubborn to believe it lol

[Stocking]

Elaborate.

you were with the lord tony bandwagon of handicaps that was dead-set on proving that i wasnt a girl

the only reason youre trying to act all holier-than-thou is because youre upset you werent the one to expose pie crust yourself, and you dont like that the people who actually put in the work are the people getting attention for it

[Flatflyer]

we're not denying carlota's existance
just denying that carlota is not pc

well we've confirmed Pie crust does indeed have a sister/brother so we know that could be a possibility