Poll

Does media violence have an impact on aggression in children?

Yes
No
Other (Post)

Author Topic: The effect of media violence on children  (Read 2257 times)


tons of factors to put into account for the kid, it depends
it does iirc
ive seen if from a few different sources but yeah its bc we understand like, the expense of human life or smth by comparing the disposable lives of virtual people vs actual lives that can't be brought back ever

i just realized i read your comment wrong but
yeah it actually
you really need to finish your sentences

only if they lack the ability to perceive fiction from reality

I think it depends on age and maturity mostly. The younger and more immature they are, the more games will be influential on them

I think games definitely make people frustrated. I don't see how it could make people more aggressive unless they're very impressionable (like people below the age of 11) and ingesting very violent content

I say no, but I have to admit:
After I played GTA V story mode for awhile, I had been hunting for gas stations to rob. I would look for a gas station with a highly detailed interior so I knew I could rob it.

But one day while my dad and I were driving past a gas station whose interior was highly detailed,

And for a second I thought, "Rob it."

I think it can for the really young ones. like, I have three stepbrothers, who are small, one is four, one is six, and one is nine
they all play video games, but only the youngest one is violent. he hits people all the time for the smallest reasons, which I imagine comes from the fact that he is allowed to do that in games like Fallout
but, I'm not 100% sure, because he also becomes violent in video games for the smallest reasons, if for any reason at all, even when he's playing something like minecraft with real people. so maybe it has a deeper cause

only if they lack the ability to perceive fiction from reality
As you may or may not know I have a problem perceiving reality from fake, at times things mess up and I may not know if I'm asleep or awake. However, I'm not going around and shanking people for walking on the sidewalk.

You should worry more about people like
I say no, but I have to admit:
After I played GTA V story mode for awhile, I had been hunting for gas stations to rob. I would look for a gas station with a highly detailed interior so I knew I could rob it.

But one day while my dad and I were driving past a gas station whose interior was highly detailed,

And for a second I thought, "Rob it."
This guy ^

Violent kids are violent kids. You have to have something messed up with you or your family if you make it through childhood thinking that hurting people is okay/good.

Violent kids are violent kids. You have to have something messed up with you or your family if you make it through childhood thinking that hurting people is okay/good.
I say no, but I have to admit:
After I played GTA V story mode for awhile, I had been hunting for gas stations to rob. I would look for a gas station with a highly detailed interior so I knew I could rob it.

But one day while my dad and I were driving past a gas station whose interior was highly detailed,

And for a second I thought, "Rob it."
guess whats going to happen to this guy

DiceyGrammar = Boltster.

This has been known for quite a while.
stuff i've been trying to remember his old name for like a week

Yes if we're talking about smaller children and things like video game culture and television.

Younger audiences are more vulnerable to having mindsets that are aggressive but will most likely grow out of it once they get older and more experienced/mature.

guess whats going to happen to this guy
It was just a force of habit and only for a split second

I usually associate the term "The Media" with news corporations like CNN and Fox News. So im going to assume thats what you mean. If that is the case, I wholeheartedly say "no". News corporations usually only report on violence, not actually showing it most of the time (except for footage from gas station security tapes and spectator videos of plane crashes, that sort of stuff).

But if you are referring to "media" in the sense of video games, TV Shows and movies, then yes, I completely believe that the things children watch and interact with affect their behavior. That's simple and basic Psychology 101. I remember when I was 8 years old and I got to start playing Call of Duty 2. It significantly altered my behavior in that I was oftentimes pretending I was in the game when in reality I was in average everyday real life, at the grocery store with my mom or playing in the house going "Die, Jerries!" and "MG-42 on the hill! Take cover!". There were several incidents where I actually hit other kids or inappropriately interrupted social situations where adults were talking at a house party or sunday school gathering.

Also consider that children are by far much more easily decieved and influenced than at any other age. History is full of examples of societies where children are indoctrinated from a very young age. North Korea where kindergarten and pre-K kids are taught all about "the great leader", or various corrupt Islamic states in the modern middle-east, where children are trained from a young age from groups like the Taliban and CIA to hate americans and sometimes even be Self Delete bombers.
This goes for the west too. There are a great many children across the south US who are forcibly indoctrinated about Christianity from a young age, but are never actually in a loving relationship with Jesus, but rather just following along in the motonous routine of dead religion in a children's suit/tie or collared shirt on sunday mornings. Those types of kids end up growing up to go into their high school and college science and history classes to finally have the final smack to the glass shatter their lifestyle of empty religion. I'm willing to bet that's the common background story for most of the young adults and teens in my school and area that consider themselves agnostic or atheist.

By no means though am I saying true Christianity is this way. Sadly the majority of "Christians" in the US are nothing more but phonies. They are simply following the robotic and loveless routines established by their super-conservative parents or grandparents. I've seen it before in the churches I used to attend; the Megachurch in downtown Jacksonville. There were hundreds of kids in my sunday school class then but I could only name a handful of people out of that entire group that really had chosen to follow Jesus rather than simply following along in dead religion.
I'm lucky now to be going to a small church that's an extended campus of my former megachurch, and down here, the people actually love one another and care for each other, and they really have a heart for the Lord. It's the best thing in the world to me.
« Last Edit: August 10, 2014, 11:41:45 PM by Planr »

There are plenty of environmental factors that can affect children. It's common knowledge that children brains are very manipulable, like puddy or play-dough. Media violence can affect some children but not all despite what the 'press' says.
Another factor that can affect a child is if whether they have a mental illness; sociopathy, psychopathy, etc. This can be still influenced also by their environment.

I grew up around a lot of violence and also play a lot of violent games like Battlefield, CoD, GTA, Half-Life. I was also raised by a single-mother and still to this day live below the poverty line. I've also seen plenty of things on the internet that no one else should see, such as beheadings, executions, hit-and-runs, and that folly. I see certain people, those who do more harm than good, as deserving to die, sure, but I don't think killing people is fun or that anyone deserves it unless they've bargained for it.

this is just mostly my opinion though.