depends, was said walmart toy gun an airsoft with no orange tip? Was said orange tip blocked, covered/obscured. Was said man brandishing said toy gun like a real one. Is said toy gun brightly colored or looks like the real deal.
Tons of fishy on both sides if you ask me.
Iirc it was an airsoft or BBgun, which either do or don't have distinctive tips. The one I had didn't but it was obviously fake.
Still, your preemptive years of training tells you to immediately shoot even when shots have not been reported and no one is hurt?
Seems particularly fishy in the case of the police to me.