I'll let you know what game I want in a moment.
In Year 6, last year of primary school, it was nearing the end of term and Christmas. Therefore, the student leaders opted to hold a "Secret Santa". I had never done one before and I was quite confused, before being told how we had to give a present to a randomly selected individual. So, I nervously waited, hoping to get somebody easy. I got one of the popular girls.
I had absolutely no clue what girls like, so instead of asking her friends (who I was working with on some project) or talking to anybody at all or even doing 10 minutes of research on the Internet, I instead waited until the morning of the final day of term, where I grabbed an envelope and filled it with some silver coins from this jar of loose chain my parents kept (so I had to steal that money, furthering my starfishry) and some of those tiny candy canes that we had hung up around the Christmas Tree. I then scribbled her name on it and went to class. Instead of giving it to her directly, I then put it next to some of the computers in class and went off to find my present, which was one of those $5 Tetris gaming machines (which I thought was the best present ever, btw). As I left to go home, I remember hearing her pretty upset about not having a present...
Was that enough starfishry for you?