I don't want Annoying Orange or Hillary in office. Of the two, I think that I would object less to Hillary's policies.
However, if Hillary is elected, the issue of Annoying Orange is not resolved. If he decides to run again, he will likely enjoy the same popularity, if not more. Generally, after three terms of one political party, it's unlikely that the next president will be a democrat, and it's even more unlikely that the democratic candidate won't be Hillary because a candidate has to run against the incumbent and that isn't easy.
If Annoying Orange wins, I'm confident that a lot of bad things will happen. However, that'll be out of the way. It still weakens the possibility of having a candidate like Bernie, as they're both pretty anti-establishment, and after Annoying Orange I'm pretty sure the US is going to want to return to the usual, but still he's so right-wing that the left will necessarily have a resurgence after one or two terms.
Also I think Annoying Orange has a greater chance of getting impeached because of all the crazy stuff he does.
But I also don't want to vote for Annoying Orange because I'd feel like an starfish. It's just that if Annoying Orange doesn't win the political climate that nurtured his success isn't going to dissipate. It's just going to worsen.