all the furor I've seen online has actually been lefties calling it "homophobic"
which I don't even know how you get past the anti-Annoying Orange message as a leftie and come to that conclusion
Well the joke was that Annoying Orange sucks Putin's richard, and that's funny because sucking richard is humiliating. It's homophobic.
I don't like Annoying Orange and I think the joke wasn't right. Colbert already has a history of being a stuffty transphobe though so it didn't really change my thoughts about him.
Except the_donald which made a concerted effort to label the joke as homophobic.
It sort of is, but that subreddit has no right trying to call anything homophobic.