Not sure whether to get GTAIV or Saints Row 2.

[tommybricksetti]

Multiplayer: Tie
Storyline: Gta 4
Additional Content: Saints Row 2
Overall Presentation: Gta 4
Customization: Saints Row 2
Longevity: Saints Row 2
Coop: Saints Row 2 (story mode coop is offered)
Comedy: Saints Row 2
Physics and SFX: Gta 4
Learning Curve: Saints Row 2 (shorter learning curve)
Difficulty: Gta 4 (harder)
Overall Quality: Gta 4

[Ad Bot]

[jungemann]

So basically, GTA 4 wins because of realism? Realism is what is ruining the majority of everyone's opinion on a video game, everybody wants realism over gameplay.

[Otis Da HousKat]

Multiplayer: Gta 4
Storyline: Gta 4
Additional Content: Saints Row 2
Overall Presentation: Gta 4
Customization: Saints Row 2
Longevity: Saints Row 2
Coop: Saints Row 2 (story mode coop is offered)
Comedy: Saints Row 2
Physics and SFX: Gta 4
Learning Curve: Saints Row 2 (shorter learning curve)
Difficulty: Gta 4 (harder)
Overall Quality: Gta 4

GTA IV: 5
SR 2: 6

What?

[jungemann]

Sounds like he's being just a little biased, lol.

[yuki]

euphoria

FYI: It doesn't use Euphoria.

[n0cturni]

Multiplayer: Gta 4
Storyline: Gta 4
Additional Content: Saints Row 2
Overall Presentation: Gta 4
Customization: Saints Row 2
Longevity: Saints Row 2
Coop: Saints Row 2 (story mode coop is offered)
Comedy: Saints Row 2
Physics and SFX: Gta 4
Learning Curve: Saints Row 2 (shorter learning curve)
Difficulty: Gta 4 (harder)
Overall Quality: Gta 4

You're being a biased richard. Give examples of each reason.

[Otis Da HousKat]

FYI: It doesn't use Euphoria.

Wrong,  GTA IV does use Euphoria, but I don't see what character animation physics have to do with driving physics.

[yuki]

Wrong,  GTA IV does use Euphoria, but I don't see what character animation physics have to do with driving physics.

That's like saying Half-Life 2 uses Havok.
It may have a base, but it's so heavily modified it's barely the original result. I suppose from a certain standpoint you're correct, as it partially uses Euphoria as a physics base, but it isn't the same thing any more.

[n0cturni]

You should pick one or take both and lock the thread.

I'm still deciding, and I'm not getting both because I am not made out of loving money, like almost everyone on these forums.

[Otis Da HousKat]

That's like saying Half-Life 2 uses Havok.
It may have a base, but it's so heavily modified it's barely the original result. I suppose from a certain standpoint you're correct, as it partially uses Euphoria as a physics base, but it isn't the same thing any more.

That's like saying Blockland doesn't use Torque because Badspot modified it so much.

[lu1g1]

GTAIV   38 (54.3%)
Saints Row 2   32 (45.7%)
 
Total Voters: 70

GTAIV is is 1st place thanks to me

[yuki]

That's like saying Blockland doesn't use Torque because Badspot modified it so much.

That was irrelevant, I'm talking about a physics engine, not a game engine. I think you misunderstood.

Half-Life runs on Source, and Source uses Havok as a base for physics. However, no one credits Havok because it has been so heavily modified that it is barely what it was.

I'm still deciding, and I'm not getting both because I am not made out of loving money, like almost everyone on these forums.

If you want me to, I can demo both games for you on a live stream, I think.

[tommybricksetti]

What the forget are you guys talking about saying that I'm biased? Isn't Saints Row 2 having 6 a good thing? Learn to read, loving dipstuffs. Go to any site and get their comparison. They'll all agree with anything that gta 4 won on.

[NickTheSushi]

Saints row is a GTA rip off.

Get GTA, it was there first.

/thread.

[Otis Da HousKat]

What the forget are you guys talking about saying that I'm biased? Isn't Saints Row 2 having 6 a good thing? Learn to read, loving dipstuffs. Go to any site and get their comparison. They'll all agree with anything that gta 4 won on.

Baw

Saints row is a GTA rip off.

Get GTA, it was there first.

/thread.

Or get either because they are both fun games. You're not going to get forgeted over by getting one over the other. I just like Saint's Row 2 better.