Remember kids, Yahtzee isn't allowed to praise games. Look at what happened with Psychonaughts, or whatever.
People wrote very angry emails.
But still, so what. He pointed out the flaws, truthfully. He didn't jump out and say "OMGOSH FALLOUT3 SUCKS CAUS IT R LIK BLIVION AND BABIS SIGN IT LOLOLOLOL!!!1!111"
He made very good points.
Yeah? So what? If you like the game, why should you care if someone else doesn't?
This is the glory of opinion. You like what you want to like.