there are cons for every item on newegg. thats not even helpful.
im tired of kids being told they must buy a whole new computer in these forums.
there are a dozen more decent PCI cards he could use also.
you want him to believe hes got no choice, ignoring his needs completely.
it only shows a lack of computer knowledge on your part, not impressing him like you thought.
If more than 50% voted 2/5 or under, it's obviously a risk to get it.
Sorry, but when I bought my GeForce 6200 a long time ago, it seemed that Nvidia and ATI stopped caring for PCI-slot owners as there wasn't a PCI card out in a long time. I didn't see that afterwards they released Geforce 8400GS and Radeon HD2400 Pro.
He said "better than 8400". So I would guess he already has an 8400GS, in fact, why didn't koolkody tell us what his current gpu was?
If he already has an 8400 then there's almost no room to upgrade, so the next step would be to get a new computer.
.