On your customization:
1. Your dirt looks like literal stuff,
2. and your water looks like paint.
3. #1 and #2: The grass is too low, and the dirt looks like stuff.
1. It's based off the top layer of this tropical / rainforest dirt, so I guess you could say that.

2. It's the most realistic 16x16 water I've seen, I just can't see that at all.
3. Yeah, I don't really like that dirt, but for grass? When I look at a hill, I don't see 2 feet of dirt.

Also, if I recall correctly, you were the guy that made that eye-raping texture pack that you spammed everywhere. No offense, but if you made something like that, you shouldn't be able to critique other texture packs.