What's there to nitpick about? The game looks great to me and I don't even own it.
People are going nuts about the game because they were told that this would be a 'next-gen defining' game and showed amazing stuff in the E3 demo that's not present in the final game
And because of being told such lies, everyone's now looking under every nook and cranny to find everything that's not next-gen about this game
Such as the lazy window reflections, lack of particles when shooting the water, the ground, etc, trains stopping and starting unrealistically, lighting looking like garbage, AI being terrible, vehicle damage being poorly done, hacking being useless, the list just goes on and on like the Energizer bunny