Other than the textures, what's different?
The previous slide of photos shows changes Space Guy suggested.
Make the bulb of the flashlight flat rather than rounded.
Make the round end parts of the barrel a slightly different colour to the main part of the gun.
Make the trigger of the gun a lighter colour.
Also in those photos (although you can't actually see it), I did this as well:
remove more polys and fix a small thing with the slide.
I liked the old light.
I can't say I liked the old one, or the new flat one. So I made another one that I like more better:

I've removed more polys, marking the count at 390. I am pleased that it continues to go down when I'm adding more shapes. :D