Red Dead Redemption vs Grand Theft Auto IV

[Illidan]

They both have their strengths and weaknesses. Besides RDR is a western game and GTA is a modern game. These two differences make them incomparable besides both being sandbox games by Rockstar

Not at all
Gameplay is almost the same. The only difference is the setting of each game.

--
I have 2 major things that make RDR irritating sometimes.
1) If you fall off a cliff on your horse, you both fall like a boulder and really fast. While you're on foot, you fall realistically. I'd really love it if the horse would do the same.

2) The map is really small, and with just 3-4 'towns' it can get pretty boring. I mean, sure, it's a really great map, but for such a vast environment, they could have added more. More caves, more gang hideouts (both big and small), more active camps, etc.

[Ad Bot]

[Hiiro3293]

2) The map is really small, and with just 3-4 'towns' it can get pretty boring. I mean, sure, it's a really great map, but for such a vast environment, they could have added more. More caves, more gang hideouts (both big and small), more active camps, etc.

I think the towns should have had more NPCs in the online, and you should buy your stuff not just get it.

ALSO: I think bank robberies online would be SO much more fun than offline

[Kevdude]

Their High Power Pistols are too strong, damn Colt.

The High Power pistol is actually a FN M1903 not a Colt 1903 pocket rocket

[Solid]

You can easily find a High Powered Pistol in Blackwater.

[Daffy]

You can easily find a High Powered Pistol in Blackwater.

Yeah but I can never get the person that I once thought would just tip their hat and move on. They're also quick on the draw when I'm running through the town with my Henry Repeater. Slow reflexes

[Illidan]

I think the towns should have had more NPCs in the online, and you should buy your stuff not just get it.

ALSO: I think bank robberies online would be SO much more fun than offline

I don't even think you can do bank robberies online, can you?

[Solid]

You can offline, but yeah that'd be cool online.

[viper30000]

that would be cool i like rdr personally better though

and for a new rdr you think they (might) make instead of it being his son that be cool if you could go to the past and live as one of those gang members but the good, bad thing would change sooo...

[No dinner for king]

I have GTA4 but i can't do stuff because i keep getting the dreaded RESC10 error D=
I'm gonna get a new video card this week though.