the fact that you guys spammed these comments pretty much ruined all chances. gg friends you made the community look like cunts
That's a bit extreme. I'm pretty sure he won't think when he looks at our comments "Wow what a bunch of cunts." Nobody has spammed up the comments, and as far as I've seen, apart from that nop nope guy, there was no stuffstorm in the comments. You guys take it over the top. The comment section, in this case, is for requests. The game with most requests will be chosen. I don't see how were making a bad impression of ourselves other than being really keen to see this game being played on his channel.
The more individual requests and likes of the requesting comments then the more our chances of getting this game reviewed. Of course, don't start making 20+ accounts each individually making a comment. keep one or two with lots of likes, and when those disappear, someone re-post.