Well having only read a small fraction of the thread, the most dismissive thing I've seen so far is to just have the single word "pretentious /\", and Badspot liked it; based on that and many other examples over the years, I'm fairly certain that Badspot's own self-imposed rules only apply to you if he doesn't happen to agree with you. This may perhaps be seen as another reflection of his inclination towards the study of jurisprudence.
On the other hand, reading trinick's stuff, I can totally understand where the dismissive people are coming from. Thinking about even trying to respond to his stuff is like looking at a plane wreck and trying to decide how to start cleaning it up; except that the wreckage violates euclidean geometry. Currently my only bookmark to this site is to the previous page because his quotestorm post was so hilarious I was almost in tears.