Both, I used an alt for that quest.
Well, stuff.But the staff doesn't expect me to take a painstakinly long time to find a player who hasn't done the quest already, or has joined the phoenix gang.:PEdit: Oh, and I didn't drop trade. I actually sold the half of the sheild to the arabian capitol's general store, and had my guy buy it from there.
Sorta off-topic:I had a nightmare about runescape last night.I lost all my quests.
Smithy, lul.