Honestly I agree with most of those arguments.
Minecraft "clone" or not, it looks like an over hyped game with stolen sprites, and since he's raking in profits for a game he cut and pasted half of the things for, he really doesn't deserve all he's getting. Seriously it doesn't even look that fun. A tile based platformer has been done umpteen times before.
>Insert a "You mad trololo" comment response here.