Sorry for huge delay. :( I've been busy participating in a show set up by the class above mine.
I-have-not's App
Even though Leo pretty much said it all I'm gonna try to point out the things I especially noted. I may be repeating Leo abit as I do not keep his review in my head and rather refrain from reading it again (you should tho :3).
Why did you choose that yellow for the beach? Use the sand color instead and I guess there's a better sea color too. What were you thinking with the shipwreck? Cut it off because you didn't want another baseplate? Silly. I actually really despise ramp terrain. But well, that's a personal taste.. but you're not getting any pluses for that from me, even though it may be a harder technique and take more time. The mountain castle is very boring and also not usable. I hate buildings that just work like decors. The site is too small to pull off a castle with an outer wall and multiple pinnacles.
Honestly, it's very well-built and pretty looking nonetheless but it isn't really up to what I am expecting from an acceptable Cohort app. You have the skills and have produced a decent app but I'm going to say no on this one.
Anti-Block's App
I'm not familiar with this kind of architecture but you have to be quite dumb to deny the quality of it.
The trees are one of the worst assets in the build. No-one else pointed that out, really? They're like pancakes on sticks. You could have used wooden beams in the interiors instead of going all white n red. Put the building on huge baseplates instead of placing small bricks to fit a little more terrain and whatnot. I don't understand you at all on this point. Also I think the courtyard is bland. Does it have an interior? The tower and main gate, that is. It's quite crucial.
The impressive roofs, very clean and basic but still splendid terrain and the superior skill in this style made me make up my mind immediately. It's a yes from me. I'm curious in how you handle other styles tho.
I want to meet up in game.
I'm pretty sure I have forgotten something, but oh well.
Welcome Anti-Block to Cohort.
