Holy crap, I forgot.
Cave Story seriously deserves a mention.
About the whole "omg SSBB is pwn" thing, that's because it's the latest thing. Think about music for a minute; Backstreet Boys were the greatest thing around 8 years ago, but things have changed, and they're pretty much just thrown into the occasional insult.
It's the same with games. What's great now won't be considered the best in 5 years, and what was amazing 5 years ago is forgotten now.