it failed in the past because there were no actual problems with the game and community. just as there isnt now.
some guy's personal issues and boredom dosnt reflect the community
It certainly reflects the general displeasure for a part of the community. It's a matter of teaching the community how to create meaningful creations.
Not everyone can disagree with a gamemode,
if it is done right.
Seriously, all those sucky RPs could be replaced by well-made city builds or thoroughly-created RPs with a plot/guidelines to follow.